The 5 Best Gelato in Orlando (For an Authentic Scoop)

When the Florida heat calls for a frozen treat that’s a step above the ordinary, nothing compares to authentic Italian gelato. The search for the best gelato in Orlando leads to charming gelaterias where this dense, creamy, and intensely flavorful dessert is crafted with passion and artistry. Unlike ice cream, true gelato has less air and fat, resulting in a richer taste and smoother texture. From classic flavors like pistachio and stracciatella to unique artisanal creations, Orlando is home to several spots serving up a genuine taste of Italy. This guide will lead you to the most delightful and authentic scoops in the city.

Gelato-go Orlando

Gelato-go Orlando

🗺️ 250 S Orange Ave, Orlando, FL 32801

☎️ (407) 930-1044

🌐 Website

🕒 Open Hours

• Sunday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM
• Monday – Thursday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM
• Friday – Saturday: 12:00 PM – 11:00 PM

Highlights

• Authentic Italian-owned gelateria
• Wide variety of classic and unique flavors
• Made fresh daily on-site
• Central downtown Orlando location
• Also serves coffee, pastries, and sandwiches

Located in the heart of downtown Orlando, Gelato-go is a go-to destination for authentic, high-quality Italian gelato. Started by Italian founders with a passion for recreating the genuine gelato experience, this spot has quickly become a local favorite. The shop is bright, clean, and modern, offering a welcome respite from the city buzz. Their commitment to freshness is paramount, with every flavor made on-site each day using fine ingredients.

The selection is impressive, featuring a colorful array of flavors that range from the richest Pistachio (made with imported Sicilian pistachios) to creamy classics like Fior di Latte and decadent chocolates. They also offer a fantastic selection of dairy-free sorbets, bursting with real fruit flavor. Beyond gelato, they serve excellent coffee, sandwiches, and pastries, making it a great spot any time of day. For a truly authentic scoop downtown, Gelato-go is a top-tier choice.

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Orlando.

Jeremiah’s Italian Ice

Jeremiah’s Italian Ice

🗺️ 285 N Alafaya Trail, Orlando, FL 32828 (plus many other locations)

☎️ (407) 277-7758

🌐 Website

🕒 Open Hours (Alafaya)

• Sunday – Thursday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM
• Friday – Saturday: 12:00 PM – 11:00 PM

Highlights

• An Orlando-born institution
• Famous for its “Gelati” (layers of ice and soft serve)
• Over 40 flavors of Italian ice
• Vibrant and fun atmosphere
• Numerous locations throughout Central Florida

While not a traditional Italian gelateria, no list of frozen treats in Orlando would be complete without the beloved local institution, Jeremiah’s Italian Ice. Founded in Winter Park in 1996, Jeremiah’s has become a Florida icon. They are most famous for their “Gelati,” a perfect layering of their smooth Italian ice with rich and creamy soft-serve ice cream. It’s a signature creation that offers the best of both worlds.

With over 40 flavors of Italian ice to choose from, the combination possibilities are nearly endless. You can create a custom Gelati with flavors like Scoop Froggy Frog™ (mint chocolate chip) or Mango. While the soft serve is technically ice cream, the combination is locally referred