The Best NY Pizza in Orlando [2025 Guide]

Searching for the quintessential, foldable, cheesy slice in Central Florida can be a quest, but finding the best NY pizza in Orlando is a rewarding journey into authentic, time-honored pizzerias. From thin, crispy crusts that crackle just right to the perfect balance of robust tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella, the city offers several spots that pay proper homage to this iconic American food. Whether you’re a purist who believes in cheese-only perfection or someone who loves a slice loaded with classic toppings, our 2025 guide to the best NY pizza in Orlando will lead you to a genuine taste of the Big Apple right here in the Sunshine State.

Pizzeria Del-Dio

Pizzeria Del-Dio

🗺️ 3210 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32803

☎️ (407) 898-1115

🌐 Website

🕒 Open Hours

• Sunday: 12 PM–9 PM
• Monday: 11 AM–9 PM
• Tuesday: 11 AM–9 PM
• Wednesday: 11 AM–9 PM
• Thursday: 11 AM–9 PM
• Friday: 11 AM–10 PM
• Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM

Highlights

• Authentic thin-crust NY style
• Family-owned with classic recipes
• Also known for Sicilian-style pizza
• Casual, no-frills atmosphere
• From-scratch tomato sauce

When you’re on the hunt for truly authentic, old-school New York-style pizza, Pizzeria Del-Dio is a name that consistently rises to the top. This beloved spot serves up some of Orlando’s most genuine NY-style and Sicilian-style pizzas from a classic, unassuming setting. It’s a place where the pizza is meant to be folded, boasting a thin and crispy crust that delivers the perfect snap with every bite. Their commitment to tradition and flavor makes them a must-visit for any purist.

The secret lies in the quality ingredients and time-honored techniques, including a from-scratch tomato sauce and hand-tossed dough. Beyond the classic NY slice, their Sicilian pizza is a thick, rectangular delight with a pillowy-soft middle and delightfully crispy edges. While they offer other Italian staples like excellent meatballs and surprisingly crispy wings, the star of the show remains the pizza. For the best experience, enjoy it fresh from the oven in their dining room to fully appreciate the perfect crust.

You might also want to check out the best thin crust pizzas in Orlando.

Gitto’s Pizza

Gitto’s Pizza

🗺️ 120 S Orange Ave, Orlando, FL 32801

☎️ (407) 203-8889

🌐 Website

🕒 Open Hours

• Sunday: 12 PM–10 PM
• Monday: 11 AM–10 PM
• Tuesday: 11 AM–12 AM
• Wednesday: 11 AM–12 AM
• Thursday: 11 AM–3 AM
• Friday: 11 AM–4 AM
• Saturday: 11 AM–4 AM

Highlights

• Perfect late-night downtown spot
• Classic by-the-slice service
• Huge, foldable slices
• Fresh garlic knots
• Central downtown location

Located in the heart of downtown Orlando, Gitto’s Pizza is the go-to destination for a genuine New York slice, especially for the late-night crowd. This spot captures the essence of a classic city pizzeria: fast service, no-frills decor, and most importantly, fantastic pizza served by the slice. The slices are huge, foldable, and feature a perfectly balanced ratio of sauce, cheese, and a sturdy-yet-thin crust that stands up to the fold.

Gitto’s is more than just a convenience; it’s a downtown institution. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or satisfying a post-bar craving, the quality is always consistent. Their garlic knots are legendary—drenched in garlic butter and served with a side of marinara, they are a must-try. For anyone seeking an authentic, quick, and delicious slice of New York right on Orange Avenue, Gitto’s Pizza is the undisputed champion.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in downtown Orlando.

Park Pizza & Brewing Company

Park Pizza & Brewing Company

🗺️ 6941 Lake Nona Blvd, Orlando, FL 32827

☎️ (407) 955-4472

🌐 Website

🕒 Open Hours

• Sunday: 11 AM–10 PM
• Monday: 11 AM–10 PM
• Tuesday: 11 AM–10 PM
• Wednesday: 11 AM–10 PM
• Thursday: 11 AM–10 PM
• Friday: 11 AM–11 PM
• Saturday: 11 AM–11 PM

Highlights

• Wood-fired pizzas
• On-site brewery with craft beer
• Family-friendly atmosphere
• Spacious indoor/outdoor seating
• Located in vibrant Lake Nona

While not a traditional New York pizzeria, Park Pizza & Brewing Company in Lake Nona delivers a high-quality, crispy-crust pizza from its wood-burning ovens that will satisfy any pizza lover. This spacious, modern restaurant serves as a community hub, pairing delicious house-brewed beers with artisan-style pizzas in a lively, family-friendly environment.

Every pizza starts with their house-made dough and signature tomato sauce, which provide the perfect base for premium, well-sourced toppings. You can build your own creation or choose from their inventive menu. The crust has a delightful char and crispness from the wood fire that gives it a unique character, appealing to those who love a sturdy, flavorful base. The combination of excellent craft beer, great pizza, and a fun atmosphere makes it a top destination in the Lake Nona area.

You might also want to check out the best breweries in Orlando.